POLITICS AMONG RELIGIOUS SCHOLARS: PROSPECTS AND CHALLENGES-A CASE STUDY OF NIGERIAN POLITICS

Volume 3, Issue 11, (2026) MSI Journal of Arts, Law and Justice (MSIJALJ)

Author: Dr. Bashir Abdullahi Ismail

ABSTRACT

The relationship between religious scholarship and political participation has remained an important subject of intellectual and practical debate in Muslim societies. Throughout Islamic history, Muslim scholars have participated in governance, public administration, political consultation, social reform and the articulation of public morality. In contemporary Nigeria, the involvement of Islamic scholars in political activities and government institutions has generated considerable discussion concerning the compatibility of religious scholarship with political engagement. While some regard such participation as an important avenue for promoting justice, accountability, moral values and good governance, others express concerns about political compromise, loss of scholarly independence, partisan divisions and the possible erosion of public confidence in religious leadership.

This paper examines the prospects and challenges of political participation among Islamic scholars, using Nigeria as its principal case study. It adopts a qualitative research methodology based on historical analysis, documentary research and selected case studies. Six Nigerian Islamic scholars are considered: Professor Isa Ali Ibrahim Pantami, Professor Ishaq Oloyede, Professor Salisu Shehu, Professor Bashir Aliyu Umar, Professor Isa Muhammad Maishanu and Dr. Jabir Sani Maihula. Their different experiences of public administration, institutional leadership, religious advocacy and academic engagement provide an opportunity to examine the diverse ways in which Islamic scholars interact with political and governmental institutions. Drawing upon the Qur’an, Sunnah, classical Islamic political thought and contemporary Nigerian realities, the paper argues that political participation by Islamic scholars should be assessed through the principles of justice, public interest, accountability, competence, integrity and independence. It maintains that neither unconditional political participation nor absolute political withdrawal provides an adequate framework for evaluating the responsibilities of religious scholars in modern society. Rather, their engagement should be guided by Islamic ethical principles and the objectives of Shariah, particularly the preservation of religion, life, intellect, property and human dignity.

Keywords: Religious scholars, politics, Nigeria, Islamic scholars, governance, public administration

Download PDF